Cash Flow Hedge versus Fair Value Hedge

A brief Comparison of Two Hedging Strategies

A cash flow hedge is a type of financial instrument that is designed to guard against any changes in the cash flows from anticipated future transactions. Companies use these hedges to lock in favorable rates or prices in advance of a future transaction they plan to complete, such as buying raw materials or selling products.

A fair value hedge is an accounting strategy used by businesses to safeguard themselves against shifts in the value of assets or liabilities that are already recorded on their books. Fair value hedging serves as a type of financial protection. A hedge can be used to counteract price fluctuations when you hold something valuable that is subject to change.

Both cash flow and fair value hedges have unique benefits for financial reporting and compliance in volatile markets, but they have different uses in risk management. Here is a brief comparison between the two:

1. Protection
A cash flow hedge protects against volatility in future cash flows from forecasted transactions or variable-rate debt, whereas a fair value hedge protects against changes in the fair value of recognized assets, liabilities, or firm commitments.

2. Recognition of Gain and Losses
In the case of a cash flow hedge, the effective portion is recorded in other comprehensive income (OCI) and then reclassified to earnings when the hedged item affects earnings. In the case of fair value hedge gains/losses on both the hedge instrument and the hedged item, they are recognized immediately in current earnings.

3. When to use
Cash flow hedge is usually used for forecasted sales/purchases, variable-rate debt payments, and anticipated capital expenditures. On the other hand, fair value hedge is mainly used for fixed-rate debt, available-for-sale securities, firm purchase/sale commitments

4. Impact on Profit and Loss
Cash flow hedge smooths earnings volatility over time through the OCI deferral mechanism. A fair value hedge may increase short-term earnings volatility but provides immediate P&L offset

5. Impact on SOFP
The accumulated Other Comprehensive Income (OCI) from a cash flow hedge impacts the equity section until it is reclassified. A fair value hedge adjusts the carrying value of the hedged item to reflect changes in fair value.

The decision ultimately comes down to whether you value balance sheet protection or cash flow stability. Both types of hedges need thorough documentation and effectiveness testing.

Complete course on ACCA SBR
ACCA SBR - Strategic Business Reporting Exam Preparation Course

Complete course on ACCA Dip-IFR
ACCA DipIFR - Diploma in International Financial Reporting

Categories: : IFRS